Coffee: Healthy or Unhealthy?

NutritionFor Patients
Written By Salvatore Melidoro

Today I’m going to ‘spill the beans’ on a hot topic. It would be an understatement to say that many people love drinking it. In fact, it is one of the most popular beverages on the planet with an estimate of 2 billion cups consumed daily (1). Yes, you’ve guessed it, we’re talking about coffee. This drink is loved for its energizing properties and bittersweet flavour. But, does it have any detrimental effects on our health? Or, is it actually health-promoting? Should we limit our intake? And, are there any groups of people who should avoid it entirely? In this article, we’ll explore these questions and more. If you prefer, you can watch the short, fun video we made on this topic instead.

October 1st is World Coffee Day, so we thought that it’s worthwhile taking a look at the science behind this popular beverage. Luckily for us, a review article was published in 2020 (2) in the prestigious New England Journal of Medicine which can help us answer the big question: Is coffee healthy or harmful? Well, coffee and its components influence different parts of the body. Let’s start by looking at what the paper has to say about the brain.

Image: World Diabetes Atlas, 2021

How does caffeine affect the brain?

Caffeine has biochemical similarities to the drowsiness-inducing molecule adenosine. By binding to and blocking its receptors, caffeine can reduce fatigue, increase alertness, and reduce reaction time. It can also improve vigilance when undertaking tasks of long duration that provide limited stimulation, such as working on an assembly line, long-distance driving, and flying aircraft. However, caffeine can’t compensate for the decline in performance after long-term sleep deprivation, although it may reduce the risk of depression, suicide and Parkinson’s disease.

What affect does drinking coffee have on the heart?

Love at first sight might give you heart palpitations, but drinking coffee, on the other hand, does not raise blood pressure levels even in people with hypertension. Interestingly though, a compound called cafestol which is found in unfiltered coffee, such as the french press version, raises LDL cholesterol which can lead to an estimated 11% higher risk of major cardiovascular events. Therefore, for those with coronary artery disease or elevated LDL cholesterol levels, it is advisable to stick to filtered coffee which has lower concentrations of diterpenes because the compounds do not readily pass through filter paper (X). In general, coffee consumption is associated with a reduced risk of cardiovascular diseases, with the lowest risk associated with consumption of 3 to 5 cups per day.

How does coffee influence cancer?

There is strong evidence that consumption of coffee is not associated with an increased incidence of cancer or an increased rate of death from cancer. Coffee is actually associated with a reduced risk of skin, breast, prostate and endometrial cancer and hepatocellular carcinoma. It can also lower the risks of fibrosis and cirrhosis, gallstones and gallbladder cancer.

What about caffeine and metabolism?

Caffeine intake can lead to an increase in energy expenditure and has been associated with slightly less long-term weight gain. Some evidence supports a modest beneficial effect on body fat. Most importantly, habitual coffee consumption has been consistently associated with a reduced risk of type 2 diabetes in a dose–response relationship.

It’s worth noting that various factors contribute to our coffee sensitivity including genetics, age and medication (3). Caffeine is gradually removed from our system by an enzyme within the liver. The rate at which we metabolise caffeine varies greatly between individuals. This explains why some people get the jitters or feel ‘wired’ for hours after drinking it, whilst others feel back to normal after an hour or two.

Therefore, the time of day when you drink coffee is important and can affect your sleep quality especially if you drink it in the afternoons or evenings. On average, it takes 6 – 7 hours to remove half of the caffeine from your system (the ‘half life’). Even 12 hours after drinking it, ¼ of the caffeine still remains in your system. So, if you drink a coffee at noon, a quarter of the caffeine will still be in your system at midnight. As a leading sleep expert, Professor Matthew Walker, points out, “Drinking just one dose of caffeine in the evening can decrease the amount of deep sleep by 20%.” (4). Therefore, to benefit your sleep quality, he recommends consuming caffeinated drinks before noon or switching to decaffeinated coffee and tea.

Coffee Blog

Who should avoid drinking coffee?

There are at least two groups of people who should be a cautious with their coffee consumption or even avoid it completely. These two groups are as followed:

  1. People with panic or anxiety disorders. Caffeine can reduce sleep quality and at high doses may induce anxiety, so those already affected by anxiety or bipolar disorder should reduce caffeine intake or avoid intake later in the day.

  2. Pregnant women. Some evidence suggests that higher caffeine intake is associated with lower birth weight and higher pregnancy loss. Even though this evidence is inconclusive, prudence suggests limiting coffee consumption during pregnancy to a maximum of two regular cups a day.

Not all plant-based diets are the same. Whilst a whole food plant-based diet can reverse disease, a plant-based diet filled with processed plant-based foods and ready meals, ultra-processed meat alternatives, added sugars and fats does not afford the same health benefits (11).

Cooking styles also influence the calorie density of our diets. Frying and sauteing in oil can add many hundreds of calories to an otherwise healthy diet. Boiling, steaming and air-frying allow you to eat as much as you like without the added fat calories. Air-fried potatoes taste just as good as oil-fried potatoes and contain a fraction of the calories.

The verdict

In conclusion, drinking moderate amounts of coffee can have beneficial effects on various aspects of health. Due to genetic variations, some people will feel stronger effects of caffeine than others. Everyone should be aware that drinking caffeine can affect their sleep quality. Even if you have no problem falling asleep after drinking coffee in the evenings, the quality of deep sleep might still be affected (5). By drinking 2-5 cups a day (ideally before noon), the health benefits of drinking coffee seem to outweigh the risks, leading to fewer chronic diseases and reduced all-cause mortality.

Watch the video

We already made a short video on this topic. Watch the video below or discover more nutrition-related videos from PAN on our YouTube channel. Don’t forget to hit the subscribe button to follow PAN on YouTube.

 

Additional Information:

Salvatore Melidoro
Previous

Seven Delicious Twists on the Humble Hummus Recipe
Next

Is Chocolate Healthy? What the Latest Science Says